Alison MR et al. (DEC 2010)
The Journal of pathology 222 4 335--44
Finding cancer stem cells: are aldehyde dehydrogenases fit for purpose?
Despite many years of intensive effort,there is surprisingly little consensus on the most suitable markers with which to locate and isolate stem cells from adult tissues. By comparison,the study of cancer stem cells is still in its infancy; so,unsurprisingly,there is great uncertainty as to the identity of these cells. Stem cell markers can be broadly categorized into molecular determinants of self-renewal,clonogenicity,multipotentiality,adherence to the niche,and longevity. This review assesses the utility of recognizing cancer stem cells by virtue of high expression of aldehyde dehydrogenases (ALDHs),probably significant determinants of cell survival through their ability to detoxify many potentially cytotoxic molecules,and contributing to drug resistance. Antibodies are available against the ALDH enzyme family,but the vast majority of studies have used cell sorting techniques to enrich for cells expressing these enzymes. Live cells expressing high ALDH activity are usually identified by the ALDEFLUOR kit and sorted by fluorescence activated cell sorting (FACS). For many human tumours,but notably breast cancer,cell selection based upon ALDH activity appears to be a useful marker for enriching for cells with tumour-initiating activity (presumed cancer stem cells) in immunodeficient mice,and indeed the frequency of so-called ALDH(bri) cells in many tumours can be an independent prognostic indicator.
View Publication
Qiao Y et al. (APR 2011)
Cancer research 71 8 3076--86
FOXQ1 regulates epithelial-mesenchymal transition in human cancers.
Epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) in cancer cells plays a pivotal role in determining metastatic prowess,but knowledge of EMT regulation remains incomplete. In this study,we defined a critical functional role for the Forkhead transcription factor FOXQ1 in regulating EMT in breast cancer cells. FOXQ1 expression was correlated with high-grade basal-like breast cancers and was associated with poor clinical outcomes. RNAi-mediated suppression of FOXQ1 expression in highly invasive human breast cancer cells reversed EMT,reduced invasive ability,and alleviated other aggressive cancer phenotypes manifested in 3-dimensional Matrigel (BD Biosciences) culture. Conversely,enforced expression of FOXQ1 in differentiated human mammary epithelial cells (HMLER) or epithelial cancer cell lines provoked an epithelial to mesenchymal morphologic change,gain of stem cell-like properties,and acquisition of resistance to chemotherapy-induced apoptosis. Mechanistic investigations revealed that FOXQ1-induced EMT was associated with transcriptional inactivation of the epithelial regulator E-cadherin (CDH1). Our findings define a key role for FOXQ1 in regulating EMT and aggressiveness in human cancer.
View Publication
Shackleton M et al. (JAN 2006)
Nature 439 7072 84--8
Generation of a functional mammary gland from a single stem cell.
The existence of mammary stem cells (MaSCs) has been postulated from evidence that the mammary gland can be regenerated by transplantation of epithelial fragments in mice. Interest in MaSCs has been further stimulated by their potential role in breast tumorigenesis. However,the identity and purification of MaSCs has proved elusive owing to the lack of defined markers. We isolated discrete populations of mouse mammary cells on the basis of cell-surface markers and identified a subpopulation (Lin-CD29hiCD24+) that is highly enriched for MaSCs by transplantation. Here we show that a single cell,marked with a LacZ transgene,can reconstitute a complete mammary gland in vivo. The transplanted cell contributed to both the luminal and myoepithelial lineages and generated functional lobuloalveolar units during pregnancy. The self-renewing capacity of these cells was demonstrated by serial transplantation of clonal outgrowths. In support of a potential role for MaSCs in breast cancer,the stem-cell-enriched subpopulation was expanded in premalignant mammary tissue from MMTV-wnt-1 mice and contained a higher number of MaSCs. Our data establish that single cells within the Lin-CD29hiCD24+ population are multipotent and self-renewing,properties that define them as MaSCs.
View Publication
Korkaya H et al. (OCT 2008)
Oncogene 27 47 6120--30
HER2 regulates the mammary stem/progenitor cell population driving tumorigenesis and invasion.
The cancer stem cell hypothesis proposes that cancers arise in stem/progenitor cells through disregulation of self-renewal pathways generating tumors,which are driven by a component of 'tumor-initiating cells' retaining stem cell properties. The HER2 gene is amplified in 20-30% of human breast cancers and has been implicated in mammary tumorigenesis as well as in mediating aggressive tumor growth and metastasis. We demonstrate that HER2 overexpression drives mammary carcinogenesis,tumor growth and invasion through its effects on normal and malignant mammary stem cells. HER2 overexpression in normal mammary epithelial cells (NMEC) increases the proportion of stem/progenitor cells as demonstrated by in vitro mammosphere assays and the expression of stem cell marker aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH) as well as by generation of hyperplastic lesions in humanized fat pads of NOD (nucleotide-binding oligomerization domain)/SCID (severe combined immunodeficient) mice. Overexpression of HER2 in a series of breast carcinoma cell lines increases the ALDH-expressing 'cancer stem cell' population which displays increased expression of stem cell regulatory genes,increased invasion in vitro and increased tumorigenesis in NOD/SCID mice. The effects of HER2 overexpression on breast cancer stem cells are blocked by trastuzumab in sensitive,but not resistant,cell lines,an effect mediated by the PI3-kinase/Akt pathway. These studies provide support for the cancer stem cell hypothesis by suggesting that the effects of HER2 amplification on carcinogenesis,tumorigenesis and invasion may be due to its effects on normal and malignant mammary stem/progenitor cells. Furthermore,the clinical efficacy of trastuzumab may relate to its ability to target the cancer stem cell population in HER2-amplified tumors.
View Publication
Croker AK et al. (AUG 2009)
Journal of cellular and molecular medicine 13 8B 2236--52
High aldehyde dehydrogenase and expression of cancer stem cell markers selects for breast cancer cells with enhanced malignant and metastatic ability.
Cancer stem cells (CSCs) have recently been identified in leukaemia and solid tumours; however,the role of CSCs in metastasis remains poorly understood. This dearth of knowledge about CSCs and metastasis is due largely to technical challenges associated with the use of primary human cancer cells in pre-clinical models of metastasis. Therefore,the objective of this study was to develop suitable pre-clinical model systems for studying stem-like cells in breast cancer metastasis,and to test the hypothesis that stem-like cells play a key role in metastatic behaviour. We assessed four different human breast cancer cell lines (MDA-MB-435,MDA-MB-231,MDA-MB-468,MCF-7) for expression of prospective CSC markers CD44/CD24 and CD133,and for functional activity of aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH),an enzyme involved in stem cell self-protection. We then used fluorescence-activated cell sorting and functional assays to characterize differences in malignant/metastatic behaviour in vitro (proliferation,colony-forming ability,adhesion,migration,invasion) and in vivo (tumorigenicity and metastasis). Sub-populations of cells demonstrating stem-cell-like characteristics (high expression of CSC markers and/or high ALDH) were identified in all cell lines except MCF-7. When isolated and compared to ALDH(low)CD44(low/-) cells,ALDH(hi)CD44(+)CD24(-) (MDA-MB-231) and ALDH(hi)CD44(+)CD133(+) (MDA-MB-468) cells demonstrated increased growth (P textless 0.05),colony formation (P textless 0.05),adhesion (P textless 0.001),migration (P textless 0.001) and invasion (P textless 0.001). Furthermore,following tail vein or mammary fat pad injection of NOD/SCID/IL2gamma receptor null mice,ALDH(hi)CD44(+)CD24(-) and ALDH(hi)CD44(+)CD133(+) cells showed enhanced tumorigenicity and metastasis relative to ALDH(low)CD44(low/-) cells (P textless 0.05). These novel results suggest that stem-like ALDH(hi)CD44(+)CD24(-) and ALDH(hi)CD44(+)CD133(+) cells may be important mediators of breast cancer metastasis.
View Publication
Eden JA (JUL 2010)
Menopause (New York,N.Y.) 17 4 801--10
Human breast cancer stem cells and sex hormones--a narrative review.
OBJECTIVE: The aim of this narrative review was to evaluate the role of cancer stem cells (CSCs) and sex steroids in the pathophysiology of human breast cancer. METHODS: A key-word search was performed using the Scopus database. Preference was given to studies using human cells and tissues. RESULTS: Long-term estrogen-progestin hormone therapy is known to increase breast cancer risk,although the mechanisms are poorly understood. In the last few years,it has become clear that many human breast cancers contain CSCs,which may be responsible for much of the tumor's malignant behavior. Very recently,the impact of estrogen,progesterone,and progestins on breast CSCs and their progeny has been studied and clarified. Most breast CSCs are estrogen receptor negative and progesterone receptor negative,although some intermediary progenitor forms have hormone receptors,especially progesterone receptor. Most mature human breast cancer cellsare estrogen receptor positive and can thus be stimulated by estrogen. Breast CSCs usually elaborate CD44+,CD24j/low and/or ALDEFLUOR+ cell markers and are lineage markers negative. One of the main roles of progesterone and progestin seems to be on certain breast cancer stem intermediate forms,inducing them to revert back to a more primitive breast CSC form. CONCLUSIONS: As the pathophysiology of human breast CSC is clarified,it is probable that this will lead to novel,effective breast cancer treatments and,perhaps,new breast cancer preventive agents. This research may also lead to safer hormone therapy regimens.
View Publication
Kakarala M and Wicha MS (JUN 2008)
Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology 26 17 2813--20
Implications of the cancer stem-cell hypothesis for breast cancer prevention and therapy.
Recent research in breast biology has provided support for the cancer stem-cell hypothesis. Two important components of this hypothesis are that tumors originate in mammary stem or progenitor cells as a result of dysregulation of the normally tightly regulated process of self-renewal. As a result,tumors contain and are driven by a cellular subcomponent that retains key stem-cell properties including self-renewal,which drives tumorigenesis and differentiation that contributes to cellular heterogeneity. Advances in stem-cell technology have led to the identification of stem cells in normal and malignant breast tissue. The study of these stem cells has helped to elucidate the origin of the molecular complexity of human breast cancer. The cancer stem-cell hypothesis has important implications for early detection,prevention,and treatment of breast cancer. Both hereditary and sporadic breast cancers may develop through dysregulation of stem-cell self-renewal pathways. These aberrant stem cells may provide targets for the development of cancer prevention strategies. Furthermore,because breast cancer stem cells may be highly resistant to radiation and chemotherapy,the development of more effective therapies for this disease may require the effective targeting of this cell population.
View Publication
Neumeister V et al. (MAY 2010)
The American journal of pathology 176 5 2131--8
In situ identification of putative cancer stem cells by multiplexing ALDH1, CD44, and cytokeratin identifies breast cancer patients with poor prognosis.
A subset of cells,tentatively called cancer stem cells (CSCs),in breast cancer have been associated with tumor initiation,drug resistance,and tumor persistence or aggressiveness. They are characterized by CD44 positivity,CD24 negativity,and/or ALDH1 positivity in flow cytometric studies. We hypothesized that the frequency or density of these cells may be associated with more aggressive tumor behavior. We borrowed these multiplexed,flow-based methods to develop an in situ method to define CSCs in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded breast cancer tissue,with the goal of assessing the prognostic value of the presence of CSCs in breast cancer. Using a retrospective collection of 321 node-negative and 318 node-positive patients with a mean follow-up time of 12.6 years,we assessed TMAs using the AQUA method for quantitative immunofluorescence. Using a multiplexed assay for ALDH1,CD44,and cytokeratin to measure the coexpression of these proteins,putative CSCs appear in variable sized clusters and in 27 cases (of 490),which showed significantly worse outcome (log rank P = 0.0003). Multivariate analysis showed that this marker combination is independent of tumor size,histological grade,nodal status,ER-,PR,- and HER2-status. In this cohort,ALDH1 expression alone does not significantly predict outcome. We conclude that the multiplexed method of in situ identification of putative CSCs identifies high risk patients in breast cancer.
View Publication
Grudzien P et al. (OCT 2010)
Anticancer research 30 10 3853--67
Inhibition of Notch signaling reduces the stem-like population of breast cancer cells and prevents mammosphere formation.
BACKGROUND: Cancer stem cells (CSCs) are believed to be responsible for breast cancer formation and recurrence; therefore,therapeutic strategies targeting CSCs must be developed. One approach may be targeting signaling pathways,like Notch,that are involved in stem cell self-renewal and survival. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Breast cancer stem-like cells derived from cell lines and patient samples were examined for Notch expression and activation. The effect of Notch inhibition on sphere formation,proliferation,and colony formation was determined. RESULTS: Breast cancer stem-like cells consistently expressed elevated Notch activation compared with bulk tumor cells. Blockade of Notch signaling using pharmacologic and genomic approaches prevented sphere formation,proliferation,and/or colony formation in soft agar. Interestingly,a gamma-secretase inhibitor,MRK003,induced apoptosis in these cells. CONCLUSION: Our findings support a crucial role for Notch signaling in maintenance of breast cancer stem-like cells,and suggest Notch inhibition may have clinical benefits in targeting CSCs.
View Publication
Visvader JE (NOV 2009)
Genes & development 23 22 2563--77
Keeping abreast of the mammary epithelial hierarchy and breast tumorigenesis.
The epithelium of the mammary gland exists in a highly dynamic state,undergoing dramatic morphogenetic changes during puberty,pregnancy,lactation,and regression. The recent identification of stem and progenitor populations in mouse and human mammary tissue has provided evidence that the mammary epithelium is organized in a hierarchical manner. Characterization of these normal epithelial subtypes is an important step toward understanding which cells are predisposed to oncogenesis. This review summarizes progress in the field toward defining constituent cells and key molecular regulators of the mammary epithelial hierarchy. Potential relationships between normal epithelial populations and breast tumor subtypes are discussed,with implications for understanding the cellular etiology underpinning breast tumor heterogeneity.
View Publication
McCune K et al. (NOV 2010)
Oncology reports 24 5 1233--9
Loss of ERα and FOXA1 expression in a progression model of luminal type breast cancer: insights from PyMT transgenic mouse model.
The classification of breast cancer into multiple molecular subtypes has necessitated the need for biomarkers that can assess tumor progression and the effects of chemopreventive agents on specific breast cancer subtypes. The goal of this study was to identify biomarkers whose expression are altered along with estrogen receptor α (ERα) in the polyoma middle-T antigen (PyMT) transgenic model of breast cancer and to investigate the chemopreventive activity of phenethyl isothiocyanate (PEITC). The diet of PyMT female mice was fortified with PEITC (8 mmol/kg) and the mammary streak and/or gross tumors and metastases in lungs were subjected to immunohistochemical analyses for ERα,FOXA1,and GATA-3. FOXA1 is associated with luminal type A cancers,while GATA-3 is a marker of luminal progenitor cell differentiation. In both control and PEITC-treated groups,there was a progressive loss of ERα and FOXA1 but persistence of GATA-3 expression indicating that the tumors retain luminal phenotype. Overall,the PyMT induced tumors exhibited the entire gamut of phenotypes from ERα+/FOXA1+/GATA-3+ tumors in the early stage to ERα±/FOXA1-/GATA-3+ in the late stage. Thus,PyMT model serves as an excellent model for studying progression of luminal subtype tumors. PEITC treated animals had multiple small tumors,indicating delay in tumor progression. Although these tumors were histologically similar to those in controls,there was a lower expression of these biomarkers in normal luminal cells indicating delay in tumor initiation. In in vitro studies,PEITC depleted AldeFluor-positive putative stem/progenitor cells,which may partly be responsible for the delay in tumor initiation.
View Publication
Luo M et al. (JAN 2009)
Cancer research 69 2 466--74
Mammary epithelial-specific ablation of the focal adhesion kinase suppresses mammary tumorigenesis by affecting mammary cancer stem/progenitor cells.
Focal adhesion kinase (FAK) has been implicated in the development of cancers,including those of the breast. Nevertheless,the molecular and cellular mechanisms by which FAK promotes mammary tumorigenesis in vivo are not well understood. Here,we show that targeted deletion of FAK in mouse mammary epithelium significantly suppresses mammary tumorigenesis in a well-characterized breast cancer model. Ablation of FAK leads to the depletion of a subset of bipotent cells in the tumor that express both luminal marker keratin 8/18 and basal marker keratin 5. Using mammary stem/progenitor markers,including aldehyde dehydrogenase,CD24,CD29,and CD61,we further revealed that ablation of FAK reduced the pool of cancer stem/progenitor cells in primary tumors of FAK-targeted mice and impaired their self-renewal and migration in vitro. Finally,through transplantation in NOD-SCID mice,we found that cancer stem/progenitor cells isolated from FAK-targeted mice have compromised tumorigenicity and impaired maintenance in vivo. Together,these results show a novel function of FAK in maintaining the mammary cancer stem/progenitor cell population and provide a novel mechanism by which FAK may promote breast cancer development and progression.
View Publication